Why 70% of platform differences are not due to gamification

Why 70% of platform differences are not due to gamification
Contents
  1. 30-second summary: the seven key takeaways
  2. The experiment that separated the two things
  3. Notifications do not do the same thing to everyone
  4. How much nudges amplify risk
  5. The study with two portfolios at once
  6. Which part of behaviour it acts on
  7. Practical steps to apply this
  8. Frequently asked questions
  9. What we do not know
  10. References

The confetti when a trade completes, the achievement badges and the trending notifications have become the favourite target of regulators and headlines. The most rigorous randomised experiment does find an effect: hedonic gamification increases trading volume by 5.17 %. But it also finds something that is almost never quoted: 70 % of the difference between platforms is not caused by gamification, but by who chooses each platform. And there is a study with real and simulated portfolios at the same time in which playing reduced overconfidence and the disposition effect while increasing two other biases. This article sets out what has actually been measured.

30-second summary: the seven key takeaways

Each row names the study and the year. It is worth separating the effect of gamification from the effect of who it attracts.

Finding Result Study and year
Effect of hedonic gamification on volume +5.17 % on average Chapkovski et al., Management Science (2024)
Where the platform difference comes from 70 % self-selection, 30 % gamification Chapkovski et al. (2024)
Who prefers the platforms with confetti Those with lower financial literacy Chapkovski et al. (2024)
Effect of nudges on risk They amplify it, especially under high volatility Chapkovski et al., J. Behav. Exp. Finance (2025)
How much financial literacy protects One standard deviation cuts the effect by 56 % Chapkovski et al. (2025)
Which biases a stock game lowers Overconfidence and the disposition effect Şenol and Onay, J. Behav. Exp. Finance (2022)
Which biases it raises Familiarity and status quo Şenol and Onay (2022)

What you will find here

• The randomised experiment that separated the effect of the design from the effect of who chooses it.

• What trending notifications do exactly, depending on the beliefs the user arrives with.

  • How much nudges amplify risk-taking, and what holds it back.
  • The study involving a live portfolio alongside a game portfolio simultaneously, and its surprising outcome.
  • What aspect of financial behavior gamification truly drives action.

The experiment that separated the two things

Philipp Chapkovski, Mariana Khapko and Marius Zoican published the reference study in Management Science: a randomised online experiment on the effect of gamification on retail investor behaviour.

Their first finding is about who chooses what: participants with lower financial literacy prefer platforms with hedonic gamification elements such as confetti and achievement badges.

The second is the average effect: on average, hedonic gamification increases trading volume by 5.17 %.

And the third is the one that changes the interpretation of everything else: the difference in activity between gamified and non-gamified platforms is mainly due to self-selection, at 70 %, rather than to gamification, which accounts for the remaining 30 %.

Why that distinction matters so much

Comparing the activity of users of a confetti app with that of a sober one does not measure what it appears to. It mostly measures the difference between two kinds of people who were already different before installing anything. The study itself documents this in behaviour: participants who prefer hedonic gamification display noisy trading strategies, while those who prefer non-gamified platforms show more contrarian behaviour.

Study What it analysed What it found What it does not support
Chapkovski et al. (2024) Randomised experiment with gamified platforms +5.17 % volume; 70 % of the effect is self-selection Experimental setting, not real money at a broker
Chapkovski et al. (2025) 605 participants from four countries, virtual asset Nudges amplify the risk taken Simulated asset; does not measure real losses
Şenol and Onay (2022) Investors with a real and a game portfolio at once Two biases fall and two others rise Voluntary game participation: self-selection remains
Agrawal and Sharma (2025) 557 users of financial apps in India Moderates planning and self-efficacy, not attitude Cross-sectional survey data, not observed behaviour
Pal et al. (2021) Financial app users, structural model Moderates attitude and planning, not self-efficacy Results partly different from the previous study

Notifications do not do the same thing to everyone

The same work includes a result about alerts that deserves its own section, because it contradicts both those who defend them and those who condemn them: price trend notifications improve the learning of investors with correct beliefs, but reinforce the trading mistakes of those whose beliefs are incorrect.

In other words, the same alert amplifies what the user already brought with them. For someone who understands the market it provides useful information; for someone with a wrong model it confirms the error and pushes them to act on it. A feature that is neutral by design produces opposite effects depending on the user.

How much nudges amplify risk

The same authors published a second experiment in Journal of Behavioral and Experimental Finance, focused on risk rather than volume. A total of 605 participants from four countries traded a virtual asset on an experimental platform whose gamified version included digital nudges — achievement badges and motivational messages — explicitly designed to encourage holding decisions.

The outcome: nudges markedly boost risk-taking propensity, especially within high-volatility settings.

And the variable that modulates the effect is the same one that appeared in the earlier study, now quantified: the effect is more pronounced among inexperienced traders and those with lower financial literacy, and a one-standard-deviation increase in financial literacy reduces the impact by 56 %.

Factor Effect on behaviour Practical reading
Hedonic gamification +5.17 % of trading volume Real, yet modest compared to typical headlines
Platform self-selection 70 % of the observed difference Contrasting users across two apps proves misleading
Nudges to hold positions Amplify risk-taking More harmful as volatility increases
Financial literacy −56 % of the impact per standard deviation The most robust protective shield evaluated
Trend notifications Ambivalent: they teach or reinforce the error Contingent upon the prior beliefs of the user

The study with two portfolios at once

Duygu Şenol and Ceylan Onay devised an experiment that circumvents a frequent issue within this domain: participants being aware of observation. The pair utilized transaction records from investors maintaining simultaneous active portfolios through an investment brokerage alongside a stock exchange simulation game, yielding a framework devoid of both observer and subject expectancy biases.

Their first finding is methodologically important: investors have different biases in the real and the simulated environment. They do not behave the same way when the money is real.

And the second contradicts the usual narrative about gamification: participating in a stock game affects all biases differently depending on the degree of participation. Overconfidence and the disposition effect can be mitigated and decrease with more active participation in the game, while familiarity and status quo biases increase.

The authors add who takes part, a figure that returns to self-selection: young, inexperienced investors with medium-sized portfolios, and men, are more likely to participate.

Which part of behaviour it acts on

Two studies with structural equation models have tried to pin down which link in the chain gamification moves. They do not fully agree, and the discrepancy is informative.

Garima Agrawal and Gunjan Sharma, drawing on data from 557 users of financial applications in India, discover that gamification substantially moderates the connections linking financial planning to financial conduct, as well as financial self-efficacy to conduct, though it fails to do so for financial attitude and conduct. Furthermore, they incorporate the features seasoned users demand: real-time feedback, progress tracking and social sharing.

Abhinav Pal and two co-authors, with an analogous model, find a partly different pattern: gamification features significantly moderate the influence of financial attitude and of financial planning activity on financial management behaviour, but not the influence of self-efficacy.

What both share, and what is worth retaining: gamification does not act on behaviour directly, but by amplifying or dampening the effect of dispositions the user already had. It is a multiplier, not an engine.

Practical steps to apply this

Ordered by the strength of the evidence behind each point:

• Do not compare users of two different applications. 70 % of the activity difference is self-selection, not design.

• Turn off trend notifications if you have no thesis of your own. They reinforce the mistakes of users who arrive with incorrect beliefs.

  • Expect the effect to grow with volatility. Nudges amplify the risk taken above all in volatile environments.

• Financial literacy is the measured buffer. One standard deviation reduces the impact of nudges by 56 %.

  • Never presume that a simulator is invariably safe or instructional. It diminishes excessive certainty alongside the disposition effect, while simultaneously boosting familiarity as well as status quo bias.

Frequently asked questions

Are gamified trading apps driving higher user activity?

Somewhat, but less than the direct comparison suggests. In the randomised experiment published in Management Science, hedonic gamification increases trading volume by 5.17 % on average, but the difference in activity between gamified and non-gamified platforms is 70 % due to self-selection and only 30 % to gamification.

What kind of users do platforms featuring confetti and badges draw in?

A specific profile, and that is the problem. Participants with lower financial literacy prefer platforms with hedonic gamification elements, and those who prefer that gamification display noisy trading strategies, while those who prefer non-gamified platforms show more contrarian behaviour.

Do notifications help or harm?

Both, depending on who receives them. The same experiment documents that price trend notifications improve the learning of investors with correct beliefs, but reinforce the trading mistakes of those whose beliefs are incorrect. The feature has no single effect: it depends on the user’s mental model.

Are they encouraging individuals to take greater risks?

Yes, and it is measured. In the experiment with 605 participants from four countries, digital nudges designed to encourage holding positions significantly amplify risk-taking, particularly in high-volatility environments, with a more pronounced effect among inexperienced traders and those with lower financial literacy; a one-standard-deviation increase in financial literacy reduces the impact by 56 %.

Does a stock game make an investor worse?

Not uniformly. When researchers examined individuals managing both a genuine and a simulated portfolio concurrently, overconfidence and the disposition effect were observed to diminish alongside heightened engagement within the game, whereas familiarity and status quo tendencies grew stronger, demonstrating that participants exhibited distinct behavioral patterns across real-world and virtual settings.

What we do not know

• What happens with real money. The available causal measurements are experiments with virtual assets, not with client portfolios.

• Duration of the effect. These trials consist of brief sessions, and long-term habituation to the stimuli across several months remains unrecorded.

• Whether the net balance is positive or negative. Greater volume and higher risk do not inherently equate to an inferior result, yet scarce studies assess ultimate returns.

• Where the boundary of acceptable design lies. The distinction between a useful nudge and a manipulative one is much discussed and little operationalised.

References

1. Chapkovski, P., Khapko, M. and Zoican, M. Trading Gamification and Investor Behavior. Management Science, 2024. DOI: 10.1287/mnsc.2022.02650

2. Chapkovski, P., Khapko, M. and Zoican, M. Gamified risk-taking. Journal of Behavioral and Experimental Finance, 2025. DOI: 10.1016/j.jbef.2025.101049

3. Şenol, D. and Onay, C. Impact of gamification on mitigating behavioral biases of investors. Journal of Behavioral and Experimental Finance, 2022. DOI: 10.1016/j.jbef.2022.100772

4. Agrawal, G. and Sharma, G. An Evaluation of Gamification on Financial Conduct in Relation to the Effectiveness of Behavioral Traits. Financial Planning Review, 2025. DOI: 10.1002/cfp2.70016

5. Pal, A., Indapurkar, K. and Gupta, K. Gamification of financial applications and financial behavior of young investors. Young Consumers, 2021. DOI: 10.1108/yc-10-2020-1240

This content serves purely informational purposes and does not amount to financial guidance or an investment proposal. The referenced research evaluates experimental environments and distinct cohorts that lack comparability, while failing to forecast how any given platform might impact a specific user.

By Ava Stringer

You May Also Like